Britain’s top court on Friday ruled that drivers at US ride-hailing giant Uber are entitled to workers’ rights, in a judgement with huge implications for the “gig economy”.
The Supreme Court’s unanimous ruling that the drivers are workers followed a protracted legal battle with the Silicon Valley taxi and delivery company.
“This has been a gruelling four-year legal battle for our members — but it’s ended in a historic win,” said Mick Rix, from the GMB trade union.
“The Supreme Court has upheld the decision of three previous courts, backing up what GMB has said all along: Uber drivers are workers and entitled to breaks, holiday pay and minimum wage,” he added.
The court ruled that the service performed by drivers was “very tightly defined and controlled by Uber” so they could not be considered to be self-employed.
The drivers were “in a position of subordination and dependency… such that they have little or no ability to improve their economic position through professional or entrepreneurial skill,” added the ruling.
“The drivers were rightly found to be ‘workers’,” the six judges concluded.
Uber said it respected the ruling, and “will now consult with every active driver across the UK to understand the changes they want to see”, according to Jamie Heywood, its manager for northern and eastern Europe.
Lower courts ruled in 2016, 2017 and 2018 in favour of a group of 20 Uber drivers who argued they were entitled to employee status given the length of time they had been working through the Uber app, and the way that the company oversaw their work.
Uber insisted that the drivers were self-employed since they choose their own hours and place of work, and often find passengers through rival apps.
The complainants can now ask an employment tribunal for compensation which could trigger far-reaching changes affecting all ride-hailing drivers.
“GMB will now consult with our Uber driver members over their forthcoming compensation claim,” said Rix.
‘Nail in coffin’
Lead claimant James Farrar said he was “delighted” by the ruling, claiming it would “fundamentally re-order the gig economy” in Britain — in which people do short-term work without formal contracts, or work without guaranteed hours.
The decision was “another nail in the coffin” for the gig economy, tweeted Rix.
Couriers for the Deliveroo food app are already fighting in the Court of Appeal in London for the right to collective bargaining.
But the Institute of Economic Affairs, a free-market think tank, warned that the Uber ruling would push up prices for users and affect the wider economy amid the coronavirus pandemic.
“When the logic is extended to other areas of the gig economy, we will see tens of thousands of young people unable to find any work at all at a time when conventional jobs will be very hard to come by,” it said.
Uber claimed that it has already changed the way it works since the legal action began, and has been looking at alterations to its business model in the United States after adverse court rulings in California.
Chief executive Dara Khosrowshahi on Monday presented a series of promises to European governments and trade unions. He said the aim was to offer a transparent and fair pay structure, and more benefits to drivers.
Uber is calling for companies in the sector to form a joint fund that would allow drivers who work for different apps to be able to access protections and benefits such as paid holidays.
Friday’s decision does not affect Uber’s right to operate in London, which has been subject to a separate dispute.
The platform last September regained the right to operate in London for 18 months, after a court overruled a decision by city authorities to suspend its licence due to concerns over passenger safety.
London mayor Sadiq Khan welcomed the Supreme Court verdict.
“It is a landmark decision for people who suffer from low pay and a lack of security at work,” he said.
“London is a tech powerhouse for the world — but employers must play by the rules.”
Airline CEOs, Biden Officials Consider Green-Fuel Breaks
Chief executives of the nation’s largest passenger and cargo airlines met with key Biden administration officials Friday to talk about reducing emissions from airplanes and push incentives for lower-carbon aviation fuels.
The White House said the meeting with climate adviser Gina McCarthy and Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg also touched on economic policy and curbing the spread of COVID-19 travel has been a vector for the virus. But industry officials said emissions dominated the discussion.
United Airlines said CEO Scott Kirby asked administration officials to support incentives for sustainable aviation fuel and technology to remove carbon from the atmosphere. In December, United said it invested an undisclosed amount in a carbon-capture company partly owned by Occidental Petroleum.
A United Nations aviation group has concluded that biofuels will remain a tiny source of aviation fuel for several years. Some environmentalists would prefer the Biden administration to impose tougher emissions standards on aircraft rather than create breaks for biofuels.
Biofuels are false solutions that dont decarbonize air travel, said Clare Lakewood, a climate-law official with the Center for Biological Diversity. Real action on aircraft emissions requires phasing out dirty, aging aircraft, maximizing operational efficiencies and funding the rapid development of electrification.
Airplanes account for a small portion of emissions that cause climate change about 2% to 3% but their share has been growing rapidly and is expected to roughly triple by mid-century with the global growth in travel.
The airline trade group says U.S. carriers have more than doubled the fuel efficiency of their fleets since 1978 and plan further reductions in carbon emissions. But the independent International Council on Clean Transportation says passenger traffic is growing nearly four times faster than fuel efficiency, leading to a 33% increase in emissions between 2013 and 2019.
The U.S. accounts for about 23% of aircraft carbon-dioxide emissions, followed by Europe at 19% and China at 13%, the transportation group’s researchers estimated.
The White House said McCarthy, Buttigieg and economic adviser Brian Deese were grateful and optimistic to hear the airline CEOs talk about current and future efforts to combat climate change.
Nicholas Calio, president of the trade group Airlines for America, said the exchange was positive.
Airlines are ready, willing and able partners, and we want to be part of the solution” to climate change, Calio said in a statement. We stand ready to work in partnership with the Biden administration.
Disclaimer: This post has been auto-published from an agency feed without any modifications to the text and has not been reviewed by an editor
- Congress attacks Modi government for reduction in unemployment rate
- The Wire publishes fake news on new guidelines for digital media sites
- Bharat Biotech completes phase 3 trial of Covaxin, reports 81% efficacy
- Japan Weighing Extension of Coronavirus Emergency in Tokyo: PM Yoshihide Suga
- Truecaller’s Guardians Could Just Be The App Your Family Needs, Particularly When They Travel
Congress attacks Modi government for reduction in unemployment rate
So absorbed is Congress in attacking the Modi government that it seems that they have taken leave of their senses....
The Wire publishes fake news on new guidelines for digital media sites
Left-wing propaganda site The Wire was once against caught peddling fake news, this time on the newly announced guidelines under...
Bharat Biotech completes phase 3 trial of Covaxin, reports 81% efficacy
Bharat Biotech announced today that the Phase 3 trials of its COVID-19 vaccine known as Covaxin, India’s indigenous vaccine, demonstrated...
Japan Weighing Extension of Coronavirus Emergency in Tokyo: PM Yoshihide Suga
Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga said Wednesday he is considering extending a coronavirus state of emergency in the Tokyo region...
Truecaller’s Guardians Could Just Be The App Your Family Needs, Particularly When They Travel
You may already be using Truecaller, the incredibly popular app for detecting and blocking spam calls and managing messages on...
ENTERTAINMENT2 months ago
She Is the Blackest Girl In The World, Yet The Most Beautiful, See The Picture
Cricket News4 days ago
Kevin Pietersen to Lead England Legends in Road Safety World Series 2021
ENTERTAINMENT2 months ago
Malaika Arora And Arjun Kapoor, Pictures From The Past 2020
NEWS2 months ago
Cricketer Hardik Pandya’s Father Passed Away, Elder Brother Krunal Pandya Left The Tournament Midway
ARTICLES2 months ago
This Makar Sankranti Is Becoming Very Auspicious Coincidence, Do Any One Of These 5 Measures, The Doors Of Fate Will Open For You